Drugs-Forum  
Home Wiki Studies Forum Groups Blog Video Images News
Go Back   Drugs Forum > DRUG-FORUMS > Opiates & Opioids > Heroin
Mark Forums Read
Register Tags

Notices

 
Thread Tools
  #1  
Old 27-08-2008, 00:14
drug-bot drug-bot is offline
Account Awaiting Email Confirmation.
 
Join Date: 04-07-2008
28 y/o Male from United States
Posts: 459
drug-bot must live here.drug-bot must live here.drug-bot must live here.drug-bot must live here.drug-bot must live here.drug-bot must live here.drug-bot must live here.
Points: 1,405, Level: 5 Points: 1,405, Level: 5 Points: 1,405, Level: 5
Activity: 0% Activity: 0% Activity: 0%
Proof nicotine is more addicting than heroin

Quote:
Comparing Addictive Qualities of Popular Drugs

(Higher score indicates greater effect)

Substance Withdrawal Reinforcemt Tolerance Dependnce Intoxictn
----------- ---------- ----------- --------- --------- ---------
Nicotine 6 4 5 3 2
Heroin 5 5 6 5 5
Cocaine 4 3 3 6 4
Alcohol 3 6 4 4 6
Caffeine 2 2 2 1 1
Marijuana 1 1 1 2 3

^ numbers are in order from left to right and are suppose to be under the corresponding headline, but the`computer messed
it up. for an example; nicotine- withdrawl 6, reinforcement 4, tolerance 5, dependance 3, intoxication 2.
http://www.drugwarfacts.org/addictiv.txt

Quote:
1994 study based on data from the National Comorbidity Survey estimated that 23 percent of heroin users ever experience substance dependence.
Quote:
The same study found that 32 percent of tobacco users had experienced substance dependence. Figures like that one are the basis for the claim that nicotine is "more addictive than heroin."
http://www.reason.com/news/show/28809.html



swim used this analogy else where but after due consideration decided to repeat it (not word for word).-
even though nicotine is more addicting, its not associated with crime, because swim believes its because its legal and cheap. heroin is illegal and therefore expensive due to the black market, if it were legal and cheap people would be able to function on it (work, not steal, family life). heres some proof- methadone is a mu opiate agonist just like heroin, and people on methadone work and can carry on with normal life, so theres no pharmocological reason why heroin addicts also couldnt. the only thing would be heroin addicts would have to dose 3-4x's a day instead of once as with methadone (which wouldnt be a problem if legal cheap and pure).

the purpose of this thread is to challenge conventional wisdom, not to encourage heroin use as its very addictive, (also its very expensive, impure, and of unknown purity; thanks to the war on drugs). heroin addiction is very painful (physically and psycologically), swim knows from personal experience. think twice before using, and if you still want to think again; but if your determined to use read throughout this forum as well as other sites for harm reduction info.

Post Quality Evaluations:
The scientific research forms a good launching point for this discussion

Last edited by drug-bot; 27-08-2008 at 00:29.
  #2  
Old 27-08-2008, 00:51
Swimster Swimster is offline
Palladium Member
 
Join Date: 02-04-2007
Male from United States
Posts: 784
Swimster is on the way upSwimster is on the way upSwimster is on the way upSwimster is on the way up
Points: 680, Level: 4 Points: 680, Level: 4 Points: 680, Level: 4
Activity: 0% Activity: 0% Activity: 0%
Re: proof nicotine is more addicting than heroin

dude, dont forget phisical withdraws and also the long duration and sedation of Heroin.
  #3  
Old 27-08-2008, 01:16
drug-bot drug-bot is offline
Account Awaiting Email Confirmation.
 
Join Date: 04-07-2008
28 y/o Male from United States
Posts: 459
drug-bot must live here.drug-bot must live here.drug-bot must live here.drug-bot must live here.drug-bot must live here.drug-bot must live here.drug-bot must live here.
Points: 1,405, Level: 5 Points: 1,405, Level: 5 Points: 1,405, Level: 5
Activity: 0% Activity: 0% Activity: 0%
Re: proof nicotine is more addicting than heroin

Quote:
Originally Posted by Swimster View Post
dude, dont forget phisical withdraws and also the long duration and sedation of Heroin.
swim didnt forget, at the bottom swim wrote about the painfulness of withdrawl in bold. he didnt under estimate its addictivness and withdrawls, he only showed evidence that nicotine is more addictive, as in more people by percentage get addicted to it .

as for sedation, one can take a dose that takes away withdrawls without making a person nod (slang for sedation), its called a matiance dose, swim use to do this alot if he had to go to work or had an important engagement, were he didnt want to be sedated; or when he was low on cash. heroins like anthing else you can have enough beers to feel relaxed or have enough to get wasted and black out. it depends on doses, it works this way for every substance, including heroin.
  #4  
Old 27-08-2008, 01:55
NeuroChi NeuroChi is offline
is not his mind
 
Join Date: 18-12-2007
Male from Earth
Posts: 4,631
Blog Entries: 5
NeuroChi is a true resource and beyond reputeNeuroChi is a true resource and beyond reputeNeuroChi is a true resource and beyond reputeNeuroChi is a true resource and beyond reputeNeuroChi is a true resource and beyond reputeNeuroChi is a true resource and beyond reputeNeuroChi is a true resource and beyond reputeNeuroChi is a true resource and beyond reputeNeuroChi is a true resource and beyond reputeNeuroChi is a true resource and beyond reputeNeuroChi is a true resource and beyond repute
Points: 21,143, Level: 21 Points: 21,143, Level: 21 Points: 21,143, Level: 21
Activity: 8.4% Activity: 8.4% Activity: 8.4%
Re: proof nicotine is more addicting than heroin

The major argument I have heard is that the percent of users who get addicted to tobacco is greater than the percent of users who get addicted to heroin. I have no source at the moment.

As far as the chart by Dr. Jack E. Henningfield, I'd like to know what studies he performed.

Withdrawal from a serious alcohol, cocaine, or heroin addiction can result in death. This is not true for nicotine. Why it was rated the highest is unclear to me.
  #5  
Old 27-08-2008, 10:45
drug-bot drug-bot is offline
Account Awaiting Email Confirmation.
 
Join Date: 04-07-2008
28 y/o Male from United States
Posts: 459
drug-bot must live here.drug-bot must live here.drug-bot must live here.drug-bot must live here.drug-bot must live here.drug-bot must live here.drug-bot must live here.
Points: 1,405, Level: 5 Points: 1,405, Level: 5 Points: 1,405, Level: 5
Activity: 0% Activity: 0% Activity: 0%
Re: proof nicotine is more addicting than heroin

Quote:
Originally Posted by Richi View Post

Withdrawal from a serious alcohol, cocaine, or heroin addiction can result in death. This is not true for nicotine. Why it was rated the highest is unclear to me.
1. one can only die from alcohol withdrawl not cocaine or heroin withdrawl.

2.swims not sure, possibly the relapse rate or rate of relapse befoe detox was completed.if swim can find any info more on the study i'll post it.

drug-bot added 435 Minutes and 24 Seconds later...
just got home from work and found this-
Quote:
Originally Posted by Richi View Post
As far as the chart by Dr. Jack E. Henningfield, I'd like to know what studies he performed. .
still cant find what methods he used in that study but found another one he did as well as one from another doctor.,
Quote:
HENNINGFIELD RATINGS

Substance Withdrawal Reinforcemt Tolerance Dependnce Intoxictn
----------- ---------- ----------- --------- --------- ---------
Nicotine 3 4 2 1 5
Heroin 2 2 1 2 2
Cocaine 4 1 4 3 3
Alcohol 1 3 3 4 1
Caffeine 5 6 5 5 6
Marijuana 6 5 6 6 4


BENOWITZ RATINGS

Substance Withdrawal Reinforcemt Tolerance Dependnce Intoxictn
----------- ---------- ----------- --------- --------- ---------
Nicotine 3* 4 4 1 6
Heroin 2 2 2 2 2
Cocaine 3* 1 1 3 3
Alcohol 1 3 4 4 1
Caffeine 4 5 3 5 5
Marijuana 5 6 5 6 4
swim also found this very valuable nugget Jack E. Henningfield and Benowitz used
-
Quote:
1 = Most serious 6 = Least serious
http://www.tfy.drugsense.org/tfy/addictvn.htm

and the web site swim got the original chart might have mis-quoted 'Higher score indicates greater effect', either way the charts are conflicting, its all confusing.

Last edited by drug-bot; 27-08-2008 at 11:05. Reason: Automerged Doublepost
  #6  
Old 27-08-2008, 11:13
Coconut Gold member Coconut is offline
Gold Member
 
Join Date: 03-07-2007
26 y/o Male from Earth
Posts: 1,476
Blog Entries: 9
Coconut must think in IUPACCoconut must think in IUPACCoconut must think in IUPACCoconut must think in IUPACCoconut must think in IUPACCoconut must think in IUPACCoconut must think in IUPACCoconut must think in IUPACCoconut must think in IUPACCoconut must think in IUPACCoconut must think in IUPAC
Points: 2,840, Level: 7 Points: 2,840, Level: 7 Points: 2,840, Level: 7
Activity: 0.6% Activity: 0.6% Activity: 0.6%
Re: proof nicotine is more addicting than heroin

Quote:
Originally Posted by Richi View Post
Withdrawal from a serious alcohol, cocaine, or heroin addiction can result in death. This is not true for nicotine. Why it was rated the highest is unclear to me.
Alcohol, benzodiazepine and barbiturate withdrawal can kill by delirium tremens. By what mechanism do cocaine and heroin withdrawal result in death?

Post Quality Evaluations:
accurate fact
  #7  
Old 27-08-2008, 21:42
NeuroChi NeuroChi is offline
is not his mind
 
Join Date: 18-12-2007
Male from Earth
Posts: 4,631
Blog Entries: 5
NeuroChi is a true resource and beyond reputeNeuroChi is a true resource and beyond reputeNeuroChi is a true resource and beyond reputeNeuroChi is a true resource and beyond reputeNeuroChi is a true resource and beyond reputeNeuroChi is a true resource and beyond reputeNeuroChi is a true resource and beyond reputeNeuroChi is a true resource and beyond reputeNeuroChi is a true resource and beyond reputeNeuroChi is a true resource and beyond reputeNeuroChi is a true resource and beyond repute
Points: 21,143, Level: 21 Points: 21,143, Level: 21 Points: 21,143, Level: 21
Activity: 8.4% Activity: 8.4% Activity: 8.4%
Re: proof nicotine is more addicting than heroin

Quote:
Originally Posted by drug-bot View Post
1. one can only die from alcohol withdrawl not cocaine or heroin withdrawl.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Coconut View Post
Alcohol, benzodiazepine and barbiturate withdrawal can kill by delirium tremens. By what mechanism do cocaine and heroin withdrawal result in death?
I should have been more specific. Children born of mothers who abused cocaine or heroin must be detoxified gradually otherwise they risk heart complications and possible death. A close friend of mine and children's aid worker has much more knowledge on the subject.

For adults, this is much less common, but still possible. I do not know the specific mechanism by which it happens.
  #8  
Old 09-10-2008, 07:53
unema unema is offline
Silver Member
 
Join Date: 04-10-2008
25 y/o Male from United States
Posts: 70
unema is a decent psychonaut.
Re: proof nicotine is more addicting than heroin

Hmm, good find but odd. I can smoke 1-10 cigs a day, 25 days out of a month then go a few weeks without one and sometime longer and never get any real physical w/d from it. I noticed one time I was getting agitated fairly quickly but that was only for a day, so...SWIM does w/d bad kicking H though
  #9  
Old 19-10-2008, 10:46
dongiovanni dongiovanni is offline
Account Awaiting Email Confirmation.
 
Join Date: 15-08-2007
Male from United Kingdom
Posts: 7
dongiovanni is an unknown quantity at this point
Points: 22, Level: 1 Points: 22, Level: 1 Points: 22, Level: 1
Activity: 0% Activity: 0% Activity: 0%
Re: proof nicotine is more addicting than heroin

Swim finds this topic a little disturbing. Swim's been a heavy smoker for nearly a decade (15-25 a day) and has great trouble quitting, mainly because he's lazy and hedonistic. Swim has also messed around a little with injecting H, and finds that after a night of hitting it, he feels shattered, and while he doesn't feel the desperation to head back out and score some more right away, he can feel how easy it would be to slip. Comparing a relatively benign chemical such as nicotine (benign in the sense that the really negative physical effects tend to be very long term, such as cancer) with a harsh, rough, amazing and euphoric chemical such as H is ridiculous and irresponsible.
  #10  
Old 07-12-2008, 04:04
Absu Absu is offline
Newbie
 
Join Date: 18-09-2008
32 y/o Male from Armenia
Posts: 22
Absu is an unknown quantity at this point
Re: proof nicotine is more addicting than heroin

Quote:
Originally Posted by Richi View Post

Withdrawal from a serious alcohol, cocaine, or heroin addiction can result in death. This is not true for nicotine. Why it was rated the highest is unclear to me.

Actually the only withdrawals that can result in death are those of alcohol and benzodeazepines or however u spell it in english benzodeacepinas lol.

Absu added 2 Minutes and 50 Seconds later...

Quote:
Originally Posted by dongiovanni View Post
Swim finds this topic a little disturbing. Swim's been a heavy smoker for nearly a decade (15-25 a day) and has great trouble quitting, mainly because he's lazy and hedonistic. Swim has also messed around a little with injecting H, and finds that after a night of hitting it, he feels shattered, and while he doesn't feel the desperation to head back out and score some more right away, he can feel how easy it would be to slip. Comparing a relatively benign chemical such as nicotine (benign in the sense that the really negative physical effects tend to be very long term, such as cancer) with a harsh, rough, amazing and euphoric chemical such as H is ridiculous and irresponsible.

benign? lol no man, tobacoo kills WAY WAY WAY more people than H around the world every year, it is actually the drug that causes more deaths per year, its going to kill you, buy chantix, now! it makes quitting a walk in the park, really. I hope this helps
And speaking of hedonistic u start taking the treatment and keep smoking for 15 more days so u can really enjoy those last ciggies ^^

Last edited by Absu; 07-12-2008 at 04:04. Reason: Automerged Doublepost
  #11  
Old 08-12-2008, 17:13
dongiovanni dongiovanni is offline
Account Awaiting Email Confirmation.
 
Join Date: 15-08-2007
Male from United Kingdom
Posts: 7
dongiovanni is an unknown quantity at this point
Points: 22, Level: 1 Points: 22, Level: 1 Points: 22, Level: 1
Activity: 0% Activity: 0% Activity: 0%
Re: proof nicotine is more addicting than heroin

Quote:
Originally Posted by Absu View Post
benign? lol no man, tobacoo kills WAY WAY WAY more people than H around the world every year, it is actually the drug that causes more deaths per year, its going to kill you, buy chantix, now! it makes quitting a walk in the park, really. I hope this helps
And speaking of hedonistic u start taking the treatment and keep smoking for 15 more days so u can really enjoy those last ciggies ^^
What are you, on the chantix payroll or something? Besides, swim drinks heavily and takes stupid risks with drugs. Swim also has a pessimistic streak that makes him think it unlikely that he will live long enough to die from smoking.
More people die from smoking than heroin because more people smoke than do heroin. I wonder what the life expectency of a heavy, daily heroin user is?
Besides, dying isn't the issue here.

Post Quality Evaluations:
This post makes very good points.
  #12  
Old 08-12-2008, 18:31
Rightnow289 Rightnow289 is offline
Palladium Member
 
Join Date: 27-08-2008
Male from Earth
Posts: 1,682
Blog Entries: 2
Rightnow289 really knows their shit.Rightnow289 really knows their shit.Rightnow289 really knows their shit.Rightnow289 really knows their shit.Rightnow289 really knows their shit.Rightnow289 really knows their shit.Rightnow289 really knows their shit.Rightnow289 really knows their shit.Rightnow289 really knows their shit.
Points: 4,315, Level: 9 Points: 4,315, Level: 9 Points: 4,315, Level: 9
Activity: 0.5% Activity: 0.5% Activity: 0.5%
Re: proof nicotine is more addicting than heroin

Actually if there were as many heroin users as there are tobacco users it still would not kill as many people as cigarettes. For example you cant die from passive smoking of heroin now can you?
  #13  
Old 08-12-2008, 21:07
teddybearpicnics teddybearpicnics is offline
Titanium Member
 
Join Date: 12-08-2007
27 y/o Male from United States
Posts: 211
Blog Entries: 5
teddybearpicnics is captain of the psychonauts.teddybearpicnics is captain of the psychonauts.teddybearpicnics is captain of the psychonauts.
Points: 117, Level: 1 Points: 117, Level: 1 Points: 117, Level: 1
Activity: 0% Activity: 0% Activity: 0%
Re: proof nicotine is more addicting than heroin

swim hates this saying, nicotine is more addicting than heroin..okay no, swim has gone many days without a cig, and just gets irritated, but if he goes without dope, it's fucking hell...i can't even type about this...lame
.teddy
  #14  
Old 10-12-2008, 20:02
dongiovanni dongiovanni is offline
Account Awaiting Email Confirmation.
 
Join Date: 15-08-2007
Male from United Kingdom
Posts: 7
dongiovanni is an unknown quantity at this point
Points: 22, Level: 1 Points: 22, Level: 1 Points: 22, Level: 1
Activity: 0% Activity: 0% Activity: 0%
Re: proof nicotine is more addicting than heroin

Quote:
Originally Posted by Junkhead23 View Post
Actually if there were as many heroin users as there are tobacco users it still would not kill as many people as cigarettes. For example you cant die from passive smoking of heroin now can you?
It depends if you're smoking heroin or not, doesn't it? Besides, it's riskier to drive a car or cross a street than it is to passively smoke. What a non-argument. What about the fact that you have to work pretty damn hard to die from a nicotine overdose? Sure, you may get lung cancer and decrease your life expectancy by 5 or 10 years, but that's not the same as ODing at 20 years old.
  #15  
Old 10-12-2008, 22:22
mickey_bee Gold member mickey_bee is offline
Gold Member
 
Join Date: 17-09-2008
26 y/o Male from United Kingdom
Posts: 1,018
mickey_bee must mainline Medlinemickey_bee must mainline Medlinemickey_bee must mainline Medlinemickey_bee must mainline Medlinemickey_bee must mainline Medlinemickey_bee must mainline Medlinemickey_bee must mainline Medlinemickey_bee must mainline Medlinemickey_bee must mainline Medlinemickey_bee must mainline Medlinemickey_bee must mainline Medline
Points: 2,651, Level: 7 Points: 2,651, Level: 7 Points: 2,651, Level: 7
Activity: 0.2% Activity: 0.2% Activity: 0.2%
Re: proof nicotine is more addicting than heroin

Quote:
Originally Posted by Junkhead23 View Post
Actually if there were as many heroin users as there are tobacco users it still would not kill as many people as cigarettes. For example you cant die from passive smoking of heroin now can you?
I dunno about that man.....if you compare lifetime smokers to lifetime heroin users.......well the cause of death for most 'lifetime' heroin users is overdose. It comes with the territory. Entirely due to its illegality of course, but that's the world we live in.

If you were talking about a society where prescription heroin was available for addicts.....(like the UK before the American war on drugs persuaded a switch to methadone), then I'd agree with you 100%.

mickey_bee added 4 Minutes and 30 Seconds later...

Quote:
Originally Posted by teddybearpicnics View Post
swim hates this saying, nicotine is more addicting than heroin..okay no, swim has gone many days without a cig, and just gets irritated, but if he goes without dope, it's fucking hell...i can't even type about this...lame
.teddy
Sorry for the double post, but yeah, I have to agree entirely, statements like 'cigarettes are more addictive than heroin' are like tabloid headlines, and make me want to shoot........

Last edited by mickey_bee; 10-12-2008 at 22:22. Reason: Automerged Doublepost
  #16  
Old 11-12-2008, 04:30
teddybearpicnics teddybearpicnics is offline
Titanium Member
 
Join Date: 12-08-2007
27 y/o Male from United States
Posts: 211
Blog Entries: 5
teddybearpicnics is captain of the psychonauts.teddybearpicnics is captain of the psychonauts.teddybearpicnics is captain of the psychonauts.
Points: 117, Level: 1 Points: 117, Level: 1 Points: 117, Level: 1
Activity: 0% Activity: 0% Activity: 0%
Re: proof nicotine is more addicting than heroin

Quote:
Originally Posted by mickey_bee View Post
Sorry for the double post, but yeah, I have to agree entirely, statements like 'cigarettes are more addictive than heroin' are like tabloid headlines, and make me want to shoot........
yeah...agreed. there have been many days where swim has had enough for either bags or smokes, and guess what he took.
.teddy
  #17  
Old 14-12-2008, 19:11
Rightnow289 Rightnow289 is offline
Palladium Member
 
Join Date: 27-08-2008
Male from Earth
Posts: 1,682
Blog Entries: 2
Rightnow289 really knows their shit.Rightnow289 really knows their shit.Rightnow289 really knows their shit.Rightnow289 really knows their shit.Rightnow289 really knows their shit.Rightnow289 really knows their shit.Rightnow289 really knows their shit.Rightnow289 really knows their shit.Rightnow289 really knows their shit.
Points: 4,315, Level: 9 Points: 4,315, Level: 9 Points: 4,315, Level: 9
Activity: 0.5% Activity: 0.5% Activity: 0.5%
Re: proof nicotine is more addicting than heroin

Quote:
Originally Posted by dongiovanni View Post
It depends if you're smoking heroin or not, doesn't it? Besides, it's riskier to drive a car or cross a street than it is to passively smoke. What a non-argument. What about the fact that you have to work pretty damn hard to die from a nicotine overdose? Sure, you may get lung cancer and decrease your life expectancy by 5 or 10 years, but that's not the same as ODing at 20 years old.
Heroin overdose is only existent because of it's illegality which leads to a
wide range of purity. If heroin were legal more people would die of nicotine than heroin IJHO. You can get lung cancer from smoking as early as 30 years old. The difference between the 2 is smoking gives you a slow and agonising death whereas a heroin overdose will kill you rather quickly.

So no you don't have to work damn hard to die from smoking

Last edited by Rightnow289; 14-12-2008 at 19:25.
  #18  
Old 15-12-2008, 14:17
Dickon Dickon is offline
Banned
 
Join Date: 17-10-2008
44 y/o Male from United Kingdom
Posts: 1,966
Dickon is a true resource and beyond reputeDickon is a true resource and beyond reputeDickon is a true resource and beyond reputeDickon is a true resource and beyond reputeDickon is a true resource and beyond reputeDickon is a true resource and beyond reputeDickon is a true resource and beyond reputeDickon is a true resource and beyond reputeDickon is a true resource and beyond reputeDickon is a true resource and beyond reputeDickon is a true resource and beyond repute
Points: 7,375, Level: 12 Points: 7,375, Level: 12 Points: 7,375, Level: 12
Activity: 0% Activity: 0% Activity: 0%
Re: Proof nicotine is more addicting than heroin

In a hypothetical dream a clam said to a doughnut "mlac mlac", and the doughnut replied in loganberry jamese (which is a difficult language, somewhat akin to Reverse Polish), and I do my best to translate what was said....but caveat lector.....

I read the first post on this thread yesterday, and was initially determined to write a scathing reply ridiculing the stupidity of researchers in the medical field, but this morning I read the article and I realized that there was a grain of truth in what was said.

However, let's look at the numbers, but before we do so I'm going to add explicitly the definitions given in the first link of the original post.


Withdrawal: Presence and severity of characteristic withdrawal symptoms.

Reinforcement: A measure of the substance's ability, in human and animal tests, to get users to take it again and again, and in preference to other substances.

Tolerance: How much of the substance is needed to satisfy increasing cravings for it, and the level of stable need that is eventually reached.

Dependence: How difficult it is for the user to quit, the relapse rate, the percentage of people who eventually become dependent, the rating users give their own need for the substance and the degree to which the substance will be used in the face of evidence that it causes harm.

Intoxication: Though not usually counted as a measure of addiction in itself, the level of intoxication is associated with addiction and increases the personal and social damage a substance may do.


I shall mention in passing the inadequacy of these definitions but leave it at that. Let's look at Withdrawals to begin with. Is it just me or is it overly convenient, or falsely elegant that we have a list of substances with the "scores on the doors" (don't worry, it's a quiz show) 6,5,4,3,2,1 respectively? Yep, in my guise as master scather, disparager, castigator and general pooh-pooher of the idiotic and fatuous I shall begin here. Let us reason from within, and begin with Alcohol getting a score of 3. I have used all of these substances on a daily basis for reasonable (or should I say unreasonable lengths of time) and the two I'd say I got the least withdrawals from were alcohol and marijuana. Now I've used alcohol to semi-serious excess, and I've definitely had a desire to use it, and I've clock watched for 12 noon, which was nearly always the earliest I allowed myself a drink. I've got itchy, but I'd have to say, for me, no withdrawal. The point of this is to say that a score of 3 must imply we are talking about long-term alcohol use. Alcohol, like benzodiazepines is lenient in that a few months daily use is unlikely to establish bad physical addiction. [Do not try this experimentally. I'm speaking from personal experience of being able to stop benzos cold turkey with little or no withdrawal after 2-3 months of use. I stopped fairly painlessly after 6 months use too, but I have fitted out when stopping cold turkey after longer use. Looking back what I did was dangerous and stupid. But I was young and stupid then, not old and stupid like now. I've found the longer-acting benzos that I used (temazepam, diazepam, chlordiazepoxide) more "forgiving" than the likes of midazolam and especially alprazolam, that to my mind (I initially wrote wind, a good typo!) seem very addictive]. If alcohol is to have a withdrawal, then because it's the only drug on the list that has a potentially fatal withdrawal, surely it should, on one rating be top of the heap? Alcohol withdrawal may be the most dangerous, but is it the most unpleasant if properly managed? I'd guess not, basing my experience on one case of serious alcohol withdrawal I partially witnessed in rehab. There was some kind of crisis (the guy in question had been drinking of the order of 2 bottles of vodka a day for 20-30 years, so we are talking serious alcoholism), and he had to go to hospital, but he came back, and after a short time seemed not too bad. By way of comparison most of the alcoholics seemed to experience no externally noticeable withdrawals, and if medicated at all were given a few days of benzos. Alcoholism to the point of withdrawal (and I don't mean shakes the next day), requires dedication to the cause.

It's a shame benzos and barbiturates aren't covered here. It would give us a clue as to the mindset of the author. OK so let's look at the 5,4,3 part of the ordering "heroin, cocaine, alcohol", and mutter and splutter about comparing apples and oranges. A crack comedown is not comparable with heroin withdrawal. A bad crack comedown is in terms of its immediate intensity (tautologically speaking!) bad. I'd all but cry even if I had heroin and curse that I'd bought "brown" instead of (as well as) "white"! Heroin barely touched a crack comedown for me. But a few hours later that insanity was gone; but do we factor that low grade next day "I want a pipe of crack, I'm listless" into the withdrawals? Probably not, that will be part of habituation more. However we score this how does it compare to 7-10 nights or more with little or no sleep and every second of the clock seeing like an eternity. I think in some sense the "heroin, cocaine, alcohol, caffeine, marijuana" scoring 5,4,3,2,1 is fine.

Now, then here we come to the bone of contention. Above heroin withdrawal we have nicotine withdrawal with a score of 6. I have just emerged from a methadone withdrawal, which some readers will probably know is documented in more than a little detail in the "Screaming in the night air" thread (in recovery and addiction > opiate addiction). I think there is a general consensus that a methadone withdrawal is about a 5-6 to heroin's 5, but I would defy anyone in good conscience to read that thread, look me in the eye and say "Dickon, that was maybe a less than pleasant experience. However I quit smoking the other month, and trust me my withdrawal symptoms were far worse than yours".

I was a 40 a day smoker, and when I quit finally I was smoking 60-80 a day. Comparable to or worse than caffeine and marijuana: yes definitely. Comparable to or worse than alcohol or cocaine: there is a point to be made, if you're going to claim nicotine has withdrawal symptoms at all. It IS hard to quit, don't get me wrong, but to claim it is in re withdrawal symptoms comparable to opiates is fatuous in the extreme. It's wrong. If I were MrG, I'd do a long line of "Ha ha"s in ever increasing size. It's not just wrong, it's really wrong. It's so wrong as to derail the credibility of the author, in my opinion at least.

Please note that what I've said so far does not refute the claim that nicotine is more addictive than heroin. The strength of this claim I now see rests on the "fact" (if we believe the research) that of people who try heroin only x % become addicted, but of those who try nicotine y% become addicted, where y>x. In this sense the claim is plausible, and puts no constraints on the severity of withdrawal symptoms.

Right let's skip through the other categories, as this post is already turning into one of my longer numbers. Reinforcement next. Cocaine. Let me quote a less than perfect section of wiki under "cocaine dependence". Sources are not given, and the grammar leaves a little to be desired but I've seen this information before, so I'm inclined to believe it: -

One study showed that a rhesus monkey named Brekke, provided with a mechanism of cocaine self-administration, preferred the drug over food that was in the cage. This happens even when the monkeys are starving. Female monkeys with offspring will abandon their young upon being introduced to cocaine, and in a few cases, mothers killed their offspring. In all cases, a monkey aggressively protected the apparatus which delivered the cocaine, and in most cases, fights to the death between monkeys occurred to secure access to cocaine. The monkeys who self-administered cocaine, did virtually nothing else. Complete disregard for food, sex, sleep, water, hygiene, offspring, and life in general was always the case for those monkeys addicted to cocaine [this was then contrasted with the more normal behaviour if the cocaine was replaced with heroin].

This behaviour (remember the definition of reinforcement is for animals too) get's a 3. Alcohol get's a 6, heroin a 5 and nicotine a 4. Go figure [If this is true, I'm never standing in the way of a man returning for a second pint at the pub. Not only will I be killed, but most likely my child and wife will be too]. If we're going to unpick this rainbow, cocaine is a 6 on reinforcement. Everything else pales into insignificance. Of the top of my head I'd place nicotine second, heroin third, then caffeine or alcohol, and finally Mary Jane. Again, giving cocaine a 3 here shows either a set of criteria to define reinforcement that fly in the face of normal usage and common sense, or results that for whatever reason are simply wrong.

The rest of the numbers do not, by my reckoning, fly in the face of common sense. Heroin is the most prone to tolerance. It's not unreasonable to put nicotine next (compare the little effect smoking 80 a day has for a smoker compared to one puff for a non-smoker).

It's a thought provoking idea, but I am not yet convinced we've got very good axes for comparison. I'd love to know how other people with experience of daily use of all or some of the above substances rate them subjectively by the above criteria, or sub-divide them/clarify them/explain them better. Without some-such even subjective scorings would be rather arbitrary.

Excuse the rambling, but hope it was interesting or intelligible at least.

Dickon

Last edited by Dickon; 15-12-2008 at 14:18. Reason: adding an "s".
  #19  
Old 18-01-2009, 00:35
doggy_hat doggy_hat is offline
Account Awaiting Email Confirmation.
 
Join Date: 10-12-2007
Male
Posts: 268
doggy_hat is captain of the psychonauts.doggy_hat is captain of the psychonauts.
Points: 298, Level: 2 Points: 298, Level: 2 Points: 298, Level: 2
Activity: 0% Activity: 0% Activity: 0%
Re: Proof nicotine is more addicting than heroin

Why is nicotine withdrawal rated so high? When people are quiting cigarettes they just think "Damn, I could really use a cigarette right now." 1000 times a day. If people get more serious withdrawals than that from nicotine, I've never heard of that.
  #20  
Old 18-01-2009, 01:27
Euthanatos93420 Euthanatos93420 is offline
Silver Member
 
Join Date: 22-03-2007
Male from United States
Posts: 1,327
Blog Entries: 1
Euthanatos93420 really adds to the discussion.Euthanatos93420 really adds to the discussion.Euthanatos93420 really adds to the discussion.Euthanatos93420 really adds to the discussion.Euthanatos93420 really adds to the discussion.Euthanatos93420 really adds to the discussion.Euthanatos93420 really adds to the discussion.
Points: 329, Level: 2 Points: 329, Level: 2 Points: 329, Level: 2
Activity: 0% Activity: 0% Activity: 0%
Re: Proof nicotine is more addicting than heroin

Have you ever been addicted to nicotine? I fucks with your head. It's on par with crack cocaine. That's a gross understatement of the level of psychological addiction that nicotine causes.
  #21  
Old 18-01-2009, 02:11
Alfa Alfa is offline
Productive insomniac
Administrator
 
Join Date: 14-01-2003
99 y/o Male from Netherlands
Posts: 27,735
Blog Entries: 5
Alfa is a true resource and beyond reputeAlfa is a true resource and beyond reputeAlfa is a true resource and beyond reputeAlfa is a true resource and beyond reputeAlfa is a true resource and beyond reputeAlfa is a true resource and beyond reputeAlfa is a true resource and beyond reputeAlfa is a true resource and beyond reputeAlfa is a true resource and beyond reputeAlfa is a true resource and beyond reputeAlfa is a true resource and beyond repute
Points: 83,277, Level: 41 Points: 83,277, Level: 41 Points: 83,277, Level: 41
Activity: 51.9% Activity: 51.9% Activity: 51.9%
Re: Proof nicotine is more addicting than heroin

'Crack' nicotine in cigarettes varies widely
  #22  
Old 25-04-2009, 22:27
Scrubbs Scrubbs is offline
Newbie
 
Join Date: 07-08-2007
30 y/o Male from United States
Posts: 77
Scrubbs needs to post very carefully to avoid a ban by negative reputation.
Re: Proof nicotine is more addicting than heroin

From SWIMS experience it is very easy to quit cigarettes for him. He don't get any withdrawals at all. It is very weird. SWIM usually only smokes on the weekends when partying and has no problems on Monday when he has to stop. By the way he has been smoking for at least 6 years. It is very odd indeed.
  #23  
Old 25-04-2009, 23:01
dyingtomorrow dyingtomorrow is offline
R.I.P.
 
Join Date: 16-10-2008
31 y/o Male from United States
Posts: 2,590
Blog Entries: 5
dyingtomorrow is living in mutualistic symbiosis with drugs-forumdyingtomorrow is living in mutualistic symbiosis with drugs-forumdyingtomorrow is living in mutualistic symbiosis with drugs-forumdyingtomorrow is living in mutualistic symbiosis with drugs-forumdyingtomorrow is living in mutualistic symbiosis with drugs-forumdyingtomorrow is living in mutualistic symbiosis with drugs-forumdyingtomorrow is living in mutualistic symbiosis with drugs-forumdyingtomorrow is living in mutualistic symbiosis with drugs-forumdyingtomorrow is living in mutualistic symbiosis with drugs-forumdyingtomorrow is living in mutualistic symbiosis with drugs-forumdyingtomorrow is living in mutualistic symbiosis with drugs-forum
Points: 8,663, Level: 13 Points: 8,663, Level: 13 Points: 8,663, Level: 13
Activity: 11.0% Activity: 11.0% Activity: 11.0%
Re: Proof nicotine is more addicting than heroin

SWIM smoked between one to two packs a day for 4 years. Then just quit one day when he decided to, with no problems or cravings or anything.

SWIM just got out of rehab where he smoked over a pack a day for over 2 months straight. Same deal.

SWIM gets caught up in the moment and doesn't always follow this: but it is very important for people to understand how mentally different we all are. The same drug can affect people completely different. Addictions are also not all about chemical substances and their biological effects.

What is "real," what is "severe" to someone from their own subjective perspective is what you truly need to consider. The most idiotic and obnoxious people are those who believe their subjective perspective is a universally objective standard.

SWIM, for instance, has varied between slender and muscular/cut his whole life, and can not at all understand how people could let themselves get fat (and honestly is revolted by it) - BUT - SWIM can't truly say that their problem with food is any more or less addictive, severe, or irresistible to them than heroin is to SWIM. People can get so freaked out in their own heads, about what the general consensus would say are totally silly things, and they can become as addictive and detrimental as a heroin or crack addiction. People really should understand this when they criticize or compare other people's addictions.

Same story with people's personal "mental issues." SWIM can't tell you how many times he has heard people tell depressed people to "suck it up" or that "they should stop feeling sorry for themselves." These types of comments are idiotic beyond belief. Maybe some of them can actually "suck it up" - but for (probably the vast majority of) others it has nothing to do with their cognitive thinking, and in very many cases could be akin to telling someone with schizophrenia that they don't need medication and should "get over themselves." Just stupid. Sure we all get lost in the moment, and in our own perspective - but those people who actually preach holier-than-thou shit to others and take themselves dead seriously about it are some of the biggest assholes on this planet.


Finally about the cigarette thing: SWIM has a bone to pick because in the rehab he just got out of, they kept saying that nicotine was more addictive than heroin, which he can't really buy as an "objective fact." Such a comparison between the addictiveness of nicotine and heroin can't really be made. Cigarettes are legal, and can be easily purchased all over the place. You can't even drive down the average street for very long without seeing a place to buy them, or an advertisement. Obviously if you are trying to quit cigarettes, this makes it a lot harder. If heroin were sold and advertised everywhere like cigarettes are, I feel extremely confident saying that heroin addiction would blow cigarette addiction out of the water. The social pressures, legal pressures, financial pressures, and extreme difficulty of functioning in society because of those artificial government constructs makes heroin addiction much harder to sustain than cigarette addiction. If their roles are reversed and cigarettes were persecuted like heroin is, and heroin was as free flowing as cigarettes are, I doubt there would be even 1/100th as many smokers as there are heroin addicts now.

And finally finally, just to throw some rhetoric in there, I have never heard of anyone sucking dick for cigarettes when they couldn't get any. Or stealing from their family. Or completely destroying their life to afford their cigarette addiction. Even if cigarettes were illegal like heroin, do you honestly think people would do any of those things for them?

Post Quality Evaluations:
Spot on analysis of this subject.

Last edited by dyingtomorrow; 25-04-2009 at 23:06.

Share this on:

Tags
benzodiazepine addiction, benzodiazepine withdrawal, cocaine withdrawal, drug addiction, heroin addiction, heroin addiction rates, heroin withdrawal, nicotine addiction, withdrawals

Thread Tools


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Interesting scholarly drug facts rxbandit Pharmacology 24 27-07-2014 16:27
Should heroin be prescribed to heroin misusers? Yes or No? enquirewithin Opiate addiction 64 28-02-2014 18:01
Purity - Opium Poppy Cultivation and Heroin Processing in Southeast Asia - DEA Report trptamene Opium & Poppy 13 07-02-2013 22:02
Afghanistan - Eight-Part Series on Opium/Heroin Production in Afghanistan Expat98 Politics (News) 3 10-01-2009 08:39
"More Than A Quick Fix" BMJ 11/01/08 Article on Prescibing Heroin to Addicts Jatelka Politics (News) 1 11-01-2008 18:16

» New Threads
Lets say it takes an hour for tea...
Last post by Alka_holic
18 Replies, 444 Views
Weaning off GHB
Last post by gthug
2 Replies, 73 Views
How Hard was it for you to get...
Last post by Alka_holic
22 Replies, 1,289 Views
4-MAR and Drug Testing
Last post by williejo
10 Replies, 3,846 Views
Quitting meth need serious advice
Last post by hoya1234
2 Replies, 146 Views
Dead Libido,orgasm - which drug...
Last post by Butter Bigsby
24 Replies, 1,226 Views
My Imaginary Friend Wants A...
Last post by hookedonhelping
6 Replies, 450 Views
Loved One addicted and withdrawing...
Last post by babalooj
1 Replies, 69 Views
FENTANYL - Questions and Answers
Last post by l0s3r
41 Replies, 21,982 Views
Using Fentanyl Patches...
Last post by l0s3r
380 Replies, 387,345 Views
» New Wiki Articles
GHB
NET

Sitelinks: Information:

All times are GMT +1. The time now is 00:41.


Copyright: SIN Foundation 2003 - 2014, All rights reserved