Coughing Matilda

[Lunar Loops]

Yet more vague anti-cannabis reporting, this time from Australia. The report claims that smoking cannabis increases the risk of emphysema (and at a much earlier age and of a more serious nature). Once again, this report uses phrasiology like "Experts say the findings suggest". This is of course suitably vague, but good enough for them to get their sensationalist headline. It fails to mention how many people were involved in the research, it fails to mention what the rates were amongst tobacco smokers, it fails to take account of the fact that the cannabis smokers were also almost certainly smoking tobacco. It also fails to mention how many cannabis smokers did not have the symptoms. Don't you just love this lazy sort of reporting? Apologies for this being the second such negative report I've posted in the last two days, but I am merely the messenger. Anyway the report appeared on Science and nature online The Australian today and here it is in full:

<SPAN class=bodytext>Cannabis lifts emphysema risk
Adam Cresswell, Health editor
March 28, 2006

CANNABIS smokers risk developing emphysema 20 years before it tends to strike tobacco smokers, Australian researchers have found.

<SPAN class=bodytext>Experts say the findings suggest the potentially serious lung condition could be more widespread in cannabis smokers than first thought. The higher temperature of cannabis smoke and different inhalation behaviour may explain the greater risk.
Emphysema reduces the normal elasticity of the lungs' airways and air sacs. Air inside the lungs has to be forced out, putting pressure on the sacs and in some cases making them collapse. It tends to strike tobacco smokers at an average age of about 65.
Matthew Naughton, head of general respiratory and sleep medicine at Melbourne's The Alfred hospital, said the research began after a 40-year-old patient came in with a severe chest infection and was found to have large cysts, or holes, throughout the lungs.
The patient was a heavy cannabis user who smoked through a waterpipe.

on error resume nextShockMode = ( IsObject(CreateObject("ShockwaveFlash.ShockwaveFla sh.6")))if ( ShockMode

[Lunar Loops]

Not sure what happened there, really should have previewed before posting as I can't edit. Anyway, here it is again:

Cannabis lifts emphysema risk
Adam Cresswell, Health editor
March 28, 2006

CANNABIS smokers risk developing emphysema 20 years before it tends to strike tobacco smokers, Australian researchers have found.

Experts say the findings suggest the potentially serious lung condition could be more widespread in cannabis smokers than first thought. The higher temperature of cannabis smoke and different inhalation behaviour may explain the greater risk.
Emphysema reduces the normal elasticity of the lungs' airways and air sacs. Air inside the lungs has to be forced out, putting pressure on the sacs and in some cases making them collapse. It tends to strike tobacco smokers at an average age of about 65.
Matthew Naughton, head of general respiratory and sleep medicine at Melbourne's The Alfred hospital, said the research began after a 40-year-old patient came in with a severe chest infection and was found to have large cysts, or holes, throughout the lungs. The patient was a heavy cannabis user who smoked through a waterpipe.

Mr Naughton said his team then decided to ask other patients whether they smoked cannabis. Over the following year, they found a further 10 similar cases among regular marijuana users, aged from 28 to 50.
In just under half the cases, standard breath tests were normal and 40 per cent also had a normal chest X-ray.
A more sophisticated technique, called a computed tomography or CT scan, picked up the problems in 90 per cent of the cases, but this test would not routinely be ordered to detect emphysema.
"The pattern we were seeing with marijuana smoking was different to that seen in tobacco smoking," Mr Naughton said.
"A tobacco smoker generally has smaller holes in the top of the lungs. What we were seeing (in marijuana smokers) was larger holes in the top and mid-part of the chest.
"It's occurring 20 years earlier and is more advanced."
Factors accelerating the emphysema might include the "incredibly hot" smoke from cannabis, particularly when smoked through waterpipes, compared with the smoke from filtered cigarettes, he said. Cannabis smokers also tended to inhale more deeply and hold the smoke for longer, and marijuana might also contain other chemicals that worsened the lung damage.

Reputation Comments on this post:

good info. thanks.

[Mr. Giraffe]

Thanks for posting that. More depressing pseudo-science. Funny how these studies always seem to come from countries with a particular burning hatred for cannabis - that's Australia and France covered in the last couple of days.

[Lunar Loops]

Yes, the propoganda machine keeps on trundling along.

[motorhead]

Yes, I find that Australia and New Zeland seem to promote and publish alot of this bunk. Gateway theory, memory loss, reefer madness, toxins in cannabis. They are deffinately not down with cannabis down under.